Local business? Support local news on Frisco.city

Back to Sport

Schottenheimer Has Several Defensive Decisions to Make

Brian Schottenheimer did not announce a change at defensive coordinator Monday. The Cowboys’ review should test Christian Parker, the players and the defensive structure against the same football standard.

Theo Vance· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

November 17, 20264 min read

Brian Schottenheimer refused to announce a change at defensive coordinator Monday. That leaves Christian Parker under evaluation, but it does not put a firing on the Cowboys’ calendar. After reviewing the film from Dallas’ 46-40 loss to San Francisco, Schottenheimer said the team was still examining where the defense stood. The answer was appropriately incomplete because the available remedies are broader than replacing one coach.

Dallas can keep Parker and alter the call sheet. It can simplify the defense, change how it teaches coverage communication or reshape the tackling circuit. It can redistribute responsibility among the defensive staff, just as the Cowboys added Mike Pettine as a senior defensive assistant earlier this season.

A coordinator change remains possible. It is also the bluntest response, and bluntness is not the same thing as diagnosis.

The Monday review should separate three questions. Are the defensive calls creating assignments the players can handle? Are the players executing assignments that are sound?

And is Schottenheimer, who has final authority over the operation, correcting the problems quickly enough? Those questions can point toward Parker, the players, the head coach or several of them at once. Treating the coordinator as the only available answer would make the review easier, not better.

One demanding test for Parker is whether Dallas can turn pressure into finished possessions. The Cowboys sacked Brock Purdy five times and could have added several more, according to Schottenheimer. Yet San Francisco gained 584 yards, scored 46 points and repeatedly recovered from difficult down-and-distance situations. Pressure was present. Defensive control was not.

Consider the second quarter sequence that the film review must get right. At 12:50, Dallas sacked Purdy for a 2-yard loss, leaving San Francisco at its own 39 on second-and-12. An incomplete pass followed before Purdy found Keenan Allen for 23 yards, moving the 49ers to the Dallas 38.

The sack created the problem; the defense failed to finish it. San Francisco eventually reached the Dallas 10 before settling for a field goal.

The sacks still had value. Quinnen Williams later dropped Purdy for a 7-yard loss after San Francisco reached the Dallas 10, and the 49ers eventually settled for a field goal. Holding that possession to three points helped Dallas. A fair evaluation should credit the damage the rush prevented while asking why other disruptions failed to end drives.

The late fourth quarter offers a different kind of test. Dallas pulled within 38-32 at 3:42 after a 66-yard touchdown drive. San Francisco answered with two credited offensive plays: Kaelon Black ran for 5 yards, and Purdy found Christian McCaffrey for a 66-yard touchdown at 3:23.

Schottenheimer identified the call as Cover 0 and described Von Miller as isolated against McCaffrey. That diagnosis makes the play a coaching question, although Miller still had to defend the route and McCaffrey still had to win the matchup.

The response cannot stop at the call. Dallas recorded 10 missed tackles that produced 91 missed-tackle yards, according to Next Gen Stats. Schottenheimer pointed to lower target height, wrapping, rolling through contact and gang tackling.

Those are specific corrections, unlike a general demand for more intensity. They also demand work from the players once the ball is in space. A coordinator cannot wrap up for them, but a coordinator and head coach can decide how often the structure leaves one defender with an unreasonable margin for error.

Simplification may help if the defense is losing time to assignments, checks and communication. It may hurt if reducing the menu makes explosive players easier to isolate or removes the disguise that creates pressure. The test is not whether the playbook becomes smaller. It is whether the next version produces fewer 60- and 55-yard disasters while preserving the pressure that produced five sacks.

That standard also keeps the review from becoming a referendum on one Sunday. Dallas has already changed personnel and added coaching support, yet the large plays persist. Parker therefore deserves serious scrutiny. So do the defensive teaching methods, the roster decisions and Schottenheimer’s oversight. A new name alone would not teach proper tackling or guarantee a sound coverage call.

If Parker remains, Dallas should be able to identify the changes in calls, teaching and practice work that follow this review. If the staff changes, the replacement should offer a concrete plan for coverage communication, tackling and explosive-play prevention. Schottenheimer did not announce either path Monday.

The right decision will be the one that can explain how the Cowboys intend to stop the bleeding, then survive the next game’s first difficult series.

Sources

Cowboys: Monday defensive evaluation

Cowboys: Monday press conference

A to Z Sports: Monday press-conference timing

NFL: 49ers-Cowboys official gamebook

ESPN: Sunday final box and play-by-play

Cowboys: official schedule

Advertisement

Share

Theo Vance· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Theo Vance writes about Frisco sports, from high school programs to the city's pro and collegiate teams.

Related Stories

More in Weather